News ·

Society of Authors Faces Its Members Over the AI Charter It Launched, Then Quit

The UK's Society of Authors helped launch a global charter on ethical AI use in October, then withdrew eight days later after members revolted. The fallout lands at its annual general meeting on November 19.

A fountain pen resting on the signature line of a printed contract in warm light.

The UK’s Society of Authors meets its members on November 19 with an awkward item on the agenda: an ethical AI charter it helped write, launched with partners on three continents, and then walked away from eight days later.

What the Charter Was

The Charter of Ethical AI Use in the Creative Industries went public in mid-October. The Society of Authors led it alongside the Creators’ Rights Alliance in the UK, the Authors Guild in the US, the Australian Society of Authors, the Writers’ Union of Canada, and the New Zealand Society of Authors, as Publishers Weekly reported.

It wasn’t aimed at authors. The idea was that agents, publishers, and prize bodies would sign it and pledge to use generative AI in a transparent, responsible way, building on UNESCO’s principles for responsible AI and a framework for protecting creators’ incomes, according to Brittle Paper. SoA chief executive Anna Ganley’s goal was to get publishers to say publicly whether, how, and where they use AI, rather than leaving authors guessing.

Why Members Revolted

Many members heard “ethical AI” and saw a contradiction. Authors argued there is no way to use generative AI ethically when the tools were built on their work without permission, and some said they were never consulted before the charter went public, as Publishers Lunch and Brittle Paper reported.

Ganley first defended the charter. In an October 15 statement, she apologized for not explaining its purpose and said the Society’s position had not changed: “There can never be any truly ethical use of generative AI” (The Writing King). The charter, she argued, was meant to drag AI use by publishers out of the shadows, not to bless it.

That didn’t settle it. On October 21, the Society emailed members that it was withdrawing from the charter it had just launched. Its stated reason was to allow time to listen to members’ views and concerns.

The Charter Is Still Live

Here’s the part that matters for American authors: the Society left, but the charter didn’t go away. As of the withdrawal, none of the five partner organizations had pulled out, including the Authors Guild. Ganley said she had spoken with all of them and that the Society would pause, gather members’ views, and take those back to the partners. Members were sent a survey, and next steps were set for the AGM.

Meanwhile, in France

The fight over where the line sits got more crowded the same week. Three tech entrepreneurs in France launched the Prix Pascal, billed as the first literary prize for books written with AI. It takes unpublished French-language manuscripts of 10,000 to 50,000 words co-written with tools such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and LLaMA, and entrants must explain which models and prompts they used, according to The Outpost and The News. Submissions close November 30, with the prize due in mid-December (CTV News).

Why It Matters

Writers’ groups are trying to do two things at once: oppose generative AI on principle, and set rules for an industry that is already using it. The Society of Authors tried to do both in one document and found its members would only accept the first. Whatever comes out of Thursday’s meeting will tell us whether author organizations can push publishers toward transparency without appearing to endorse the tools.

The Press Abides will update this story after the AGM.

Sources

Featured image: “Legal Contract & Signature - Warm Tones” by Blogtrepreneur, via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY 2.0.

← All news